3UHSDUDUORVPXHEOHVGHHPSRWUDU
&MNVFCMFEFFNQPUSBSEFCFTFSUFSNPFTUBCMFIBTUBp$-B
FTUBCJMJEBEEFMNVFCMFEFFNQPUSBSUBNCJ©OEFCFRVFEBS
HBSBOUJ[BEBEFTQV©TEFMPTUSBCBKPTEFSFDPSUF
&TUBCMFDFSFMSFDPSUFQBSBVOPPNºMUJQMFTBQBSBUPT7BSJPFOMB
FODJNFSBDPOGPSNFBMDSPRVJTEFNPOUBKF&M¡OHVMPEFMB
TVQFSGJDJFEFDPSUFSFTQFDUPBMBFODJNFSBEFCFS¡TFSEFp
%FTQV©TEFMPTUSBCBKPTEFSFDPSUFFMJNJOBSMBTWJSVUBT4FMMBSEF
GPSNBUFSNPSSFTJTUFOUFTMBTTVQFSGJDJFTEFDPSUF
5FOFSFODVFOUBMBEJTUBODJBNOJNBEFNNEFMMBEPJOGFSJPS
EFMBQBSBUPSFTQFDUPBMBTQBSUFTEFMPTNVFCMFT
.FEJBOUF MB JOTUBMBDJ³O EFCFS¡ RVFEBS HBSBOUJ[BEB VOB QSPUFDDJ³O
DPOUSBDPOUBDUP4JEFTQV©TEFMNPOUBKFQVEJFTFFOUSBSFO
DPOUBDUPDPOFMMBEPJOGFSJPSEFMBQBSBUPTFIBDPMPDBSVOTVFMP
JOUFSNFEJPEFTNPOUBCMFT³MPNFEJBOUFIFSSBNJFOUB5FOFSFO
DVFOUBMBEJTUBODJBNOJNBEFNNEFMMBEPJOGFSJPSEFMBQBSBUP
SFTQFDUPBMTVFMPJOUFSNFEJP
$OLQVWDODUYDULRVDSDUDWRV9DULR 3FTFSWBSFTQBDJPOFDFTBSJP
QBSBFMFNCFMMFDFEPSEFVOJ³O77 FOUSFMPTBQBSBUPT-PT
BQBSBUPTUBNCJ©OTFQVFEFOJOTUBMBSFOSFDPSUFTJOEJWJEVBMFT
UFOJFOEPFODVFOUBEFEFKBSVOBEJTUBODJBNOJNBFOUSFMPT
BQBSBUPTEF NN
&RQH[LyQHOpFWULFD
$PNQSPCBSBOUFTEFDPOFDUBSFMBQBSBUPMBJOTUBMBDJ³OFM©DUSJDB
EPN©TUJDB 0CTFSWBS RVF TF EJTQPOHB EF QSPUFDDJ³O BQSPQJBEB FO
MBJOTUBMBDJ³OEPN©TUJDB-BUFOTJ³OZMBGSFDVFODJBEFMBQBSBUP
EFCFS¡DPJODJEJSDPOMBJOTUBMBDJ³OFM©DUSJDB W©BTFQMBDBEF
DBSBDUFSTUJDBT
&M BQBSBUP TF DPSSFTQPOEF DPO FM UJQP EF QSPUFDDJ³O * Z T³MP QVFEF
QPOFSTF FO GVODJPOBNJFOUP FO DPOFYJ³O DPO FM DPOEVDUPS EF UPNB
EFUJFSSB
&OMBJOTUBMBDJ³OEFCFS¡FYJTUJSVOEJTQPTJUJWPEFDPSUF
NBHOFUPU©SNJDPEFDPSUFPNOJQPMBSDPOVOBBCFSUVSBEF
DPOUBDUPNOJNBEFNNPCJFONFEJBOUFDMBWJKBDPOUPNBEF
UJFSSB&TUBEFCFS¡RVFEBSTJFNQSFBDDFTJCMFGJOBMJ[BEPFM
NPOUBKF
3FDPNFOEBNPTEFJOTUBMBSBVOPT DNBQSPYEFMTVFMPEFUS¡T
EFMBQBSBUPVOBCBTFEFFODIVGFDPOUPNBEFUJFSSBJOTUBMBEB
DPSSFDUBNFOUF
-BJOTUBMBDJ³OEFVOBCBTFEFFODIVGFT³MPMPIBEFSFBMJ[BSVO
U©DOJDPFMFDUSJDJTUBUFOJFOEPFODVFOUFMBTOPSNBUJWBTFOWJHPS
&MBQBSBUPT³MPTFQVFEFDPOFDUBSDPOFMDBCMFEFDPOFYJ³O
TVNJOJTUSBEP
/PEPCMBSPBQMBTUBSFMDBCMFEFDPOFYJ³O
&MBQBSBUPDPSSFTQPOEFBMUJQP:&MDBCMFEFDPOFYJ³OT³MPMP
QVFEFDBNCJBSFMTFSWJDJPU©DOJDPEFBTJTUFODJBBMDMJFOUF5FOFS
FODVFOUBFMUJQPEFDBCMFZMBTFDDJ³ONOJNB
,QVWDODUHODSDUDWR
.BSDBSFYBDUBNFOUFFMDFOUSPEFMSFDPSUF4VKFUBSFMSJFMEF
GJKBDJ³O MBSHP FO FM CPSEF EFMBOUFSP EFM SFDPSUF Z FM SJFM EF GJKBDJ³O
DPSUFBMCPSEFUSBTFSPEFMSFDPSUF-PTTBMJFOUFTEFMPTSJFMFTEF
GJKBDJ³OEFCFS¡OBQPZBSTPCSFMBFODJNFSB-BNBSDBEFDFOUSP
EF MPT SJFMFT EF GJKBDJ³O EFCF DPJODJEJS FYBDUBNFOUF DPO MB NBSDB
EFDFOUSPEFMSFDPSUF
1RWD $POFODJNFSBTEFQJFESBTFIBOEFQFHBSMPTSJFMFTEF
GJKBDJ³ODPOBEIFTJWPEFEPTDPNQPOFOUFT NFUBMTPCSFQJFESB
UFSNPFTUBCMFT
$PODPNCJOBDJ³ODPOMBDVCJFSUBEFBQBSBUPT7%
'JKBSMBDVCJFSUBEFBQBSBUPBOUFTEFJOTUBMBSFMBQBSBUP
W©BTFJOTUSVDDJPOFTEFNPOUBKF7%
*OTFSUBS FM BQBSBUP FO FM SFDPSUF -PT TBMJFOUFT EF FODBTUSF FO FM
BQBSBUPEFCFS¡OBQPZBSFYBDUBNFOUFTPCSFMPTNVFMMFTEF
BQSJFUF 1SFTJPOBS GJSNFNFOUF FM BQBSBUP EFOUSP EFM SFDPSUF /RV
VDOLHQWHVGHHQFDVWUHHQHODSDUDWRGHEHUiQHQJDQFKDUVH
HQORVPXHOOHVGHDSULHWH
,QGLFDFLRQHVHVSHFLDOHVHQHOPRQWDMHDOD
LQWHPSHULH
&MBQBSBUPWBFRVJQBEPDPOVOJOUFSSVQUPSEJGFSFODJBM 3$%DPO
VOBDPSSJFOUFEFEJTQBSPEFGVHBOPTVQFSJPSB N"
$PMPDBSVOBDMBWJKBBQSPQJBEBQBSBFYUFSJPSBMBDBCMFEFDPOFYJ³O
UFOFSFODVFOUBMBTOPSNBUJWBTEFMQBTFOWJHPS
$POFDUBS FM BQBSBUP B VOB CBTF EF FODIVGF DPO DPOUBDUP EF UPNB
EFUJFSSB QBSBBQBSBUPTEFMBDMBTFEFQSPUFDDJ³O*
$PNQSPCBSQFSJ³EJDBNFOUFFMDBCMFEFDPOFYJ³OEFSFEQPSTJ
QSFTFOUBEB±PTWJTJCMFT/PVUJMJ[BSFMBQBSBUPTJFMDBCMFEF
DPOFYJ³OFTUVWJFTFEB±BEP
&MDBCMFEFDPOFYJ³OEFCFS¡DPSSFTQPOEFSDPNPNOJNPBMUJQP
)3/'(
*OTUBMBSFMBQBSBUPEFGPSNBGJKBFOMBFODJNFSB&WJUBSMB
QFOFUSBDJ³OEFIVNFEBE
&MBQBSBUPEFTQV©TEFTVVTPZEFTQV©TEFFOGSJBSTFIBEF
QSPUFHFSDPOUSBMBJOUFNQFSJF QFKNFEJBOUFVOBDVCSJDJ³O
'HVPRQWDUHODSDUDWR
%FTDPOFDUBSFMBQBSBUPEFMBDPSSJFOUF&YUSBFSFMBQBSBUP
QSFTJPOBOEPEFTEFBCBKP
£$WHQFLyQ
a%B±PT FO FM BQBSBUP /P FYUSBFS FM BQBSBUP EFTEF BSSJCB IBDJFOEP
QBMBODB
pt
ì
,QVWUXo}HVGHPRQWDJHP
,QGLFDo}HVLPSRUWDQWHV
-FJBBUFOUBNFOUFFHVBSEFFTUBTJOTUSV§µFT"QFOBTTFB
NPOUBHFNGPSSFBMJ[BEBEFGPSNBUFDOJDBNFOUFDPSSFDUBFN
DPOGPSNJEBEFDPNFTUBTJOTUSV§µFTEFNPOUBHFNTFQPEF
HBSBOUJSBTFHVSBO§BEVSBOUFBVUJMJ[B§£P0JOTUBMBEPS©
SFTQPOT¡WFMQFMPGVODJPOBNFOUPDPSSFDUPOPMPDBMEFJOTUBMB§£P
0BQBSFMIPT³QPEFTFSMJHBEPQPSVNU©DOJDPBVUPSJ[BEP
%FTMJHBSBBMJNFOUB§£PFM©DUSJDBBOUFTEFSFBMJ[BSRVBJTRVFS
USBCBMIPT
6TBSMVWBTEFQSPUFD§£PQBSBFWJUBSDPSUFT"TQF§BTRVF
EVSBOUFBNPOUBHFNGJDBNFYQPTUPTQPEFNTFSQPOUJBHVEBT
1BSB B JOTUBMB§£P © PCSJHBU³SJP PCTFSWBS BT OPSNBT EF DPOTUSV§£P
WJHFOUFTFBTOPSNBTEPGPSOFDFEPSEFFMFDUSJDJEBEFMPDBM
&TUFBQBSFMIPDPSSFTQPOEFBPTBQBSFMIPTEBDMBTTF
EFFODBTUSBSOVNN³WFMEFDP[JOIB5FNEFTFSFODBTUSBEP
EFBDPSEPDPNPEJBHSBNBEFNPOUBHFN0CTFSWBSBEJTU¢ODJB
NOJNBBU© TQBSFEFTMBUFSBJTQBSFEFQPTUFSJPSPVQF§BTEP
N³WFM
&TUFBQBSFMIPO£PGPJQSFWJTUPQBSBTFSVUJMJ[BEPDPNVN
UFNQPSJ[BEPSFYUFSOPPVVNUFMFDPNBOEPFYUFSOP
3UHSDUDURVPyYHLVGHHQFDVWUDU
0N³WFMEFFODBTUSBSUFNEFTFSSFTJTUFOUFBUFNQFSBUVSBTBU©
p$"Q³TPTUSBCBMIPTEFSFDPSUFUFNEFGJDBSBTTFHVSBEBB
FTUBCJMJEBEFEPN³WFMEFFODBTUSBS
&GFDUVBSPSFDPSUFOPUBNQPEFDP[JOIBQBSBVNPVNBJT
BQBSFMIPT7BSJPEFBDPSEPDPNPEJBHSBNBEFNPOUBHFN0
¢OHVMP EB TVQFSGDJF EF DPSUF BU© BP UBNQP EF DP[JOIB UFN EF TFS
OPNOJNPEFp
3FNPWFSBTFSSBEVSBBQ³TPTUSBCBMIPTEFDPSUF4FMBSBT
TVQFSGDJFTEFDPSUFEFGPSNBSFTJTUFOUFBPDBMPS
0CTFSWBSBEJTU¢ODJBNOJNBEFNNFOUSFPMBEPJOGFSJPSEP
BQBSFMIPFQF§BTEPN³WFM
"NPOUBHFNUFNEFBTTFHVSBSBQSPUFD§£PDPOUSBDPOUBDUP4F
BQ³T B NPOUBHFN GPS QPTTWFM UPDBS OB QBSUF JOGFSJPS EP BQBSFMIP
©OFDFTT¡SJPNPOUBSVNGVOEPGBMTPRVFBQFOBTQPTTBTFS
SFNPWJEP DPN GFSSBNFOUB 0CTFSWBS B EJTU¢ODJB NOJNB EF NN
FOUSFPGVOEPGBMTPFPMBEPJOGFSJPSEPBQBSFMIP
1RFDVRGHPRQWDJHPGHYiULRVDSDUHOKRV9DULR PCTFSWBSP
FTQB§POFDFTT¡SJPQBSBBS©HVBEFVOJ£P77 FOUSFPT
BQBSFMIPT0TBQBSFMIPTUBNC©NQPEFNTFSNPOUBEPTFN
SFDPSUFT JOEJWJEVBJT NFEJBOUF PCTFSW¢ODJB EB EJTU¢ODJB NOJNB EF
NNFOUSFPTNFTNPT
/LJDomRHOpFWULFD
7FSJGJDBSBJOTUBMB§£PEBDBTBBOUFTEFMJHBSPBQBSFMIP7FSJGJDBS
TFBJOTUBMB§£PFM©DUSJDBEBDBTBEJTQµFEFGVTWFJTBEFRVBEPT
"UFOT£PFBGSFRVªODJBEPBQBSFMIPUªNEFDPSSFTQPOEFS
JOTUBMB§£PFM©DUSJDB WFSQMBDBEFDBSBDUFSTUJDBT
0BQBSFMIPDPSSFTQPOEF DMBTTFEFQSPUFD§£P*FT³QPEFTFS
QPTUPBGVODJPOBSDPNVNBMJHB§£PDPNDPOEVUPSEFQSPUFD§£P
" JOTUBMB§£P UFN EF EJTQPS EF VN EJTKVOUPS EF DPSUF PNOJQPMBS DPN
VNBEJTU¢ODJBNOJNBEFNNFOUSFPTDPOUBDUPTPVFOU£P©
OFDFTT¡SJP MJHBS P BQBSFMIP BUSBW©T EF VNB GJDIB DPN DPOUBDUP EF
QSPUFD§£P&TUFUFNEFFTUBSBDFTTWFMBQ³TBNPOUBHFN
3FDPNFOEBNPT B JOTUBMB§£P EF VNB UPNBEB DPN MJHB§£P UFSSB
DBEFDNBDJNBEPTPMPQPSUS¡TEPBQBSFMIP
"JOTUBMB§£PEFVNBUPNBEBT³QPEFTFSFGFDUVBEBQPSVN
FMFDUSJDJTUBRVBMJGJDBEPNFEJBOUFPCTFSW¢ODJBEBTOPSNBT
SFMFWBOUFT
0BQBSFMIPT³QPEFTFSMJHBEPDPNPDBCPEFBMJNFOUB§£P
GPSOFDJEP
/£PEPCSBSOFNFOUBMBSPDBCPEFBMJNFOUB§£P
0BQBSFMIPDPSSFTQPOEFBPUJQP:0DBCPEFBMJNFOUB§£PT³
QPEF TFS TVCTUJUVEP QFMP 4FSWJ§P EF "QPJP BP $MJFOUF 0CTFSWBS P
UJQPEFDBCPFBTFD§£PUSBOTWFSTBMNOJNB