$PMMFHBSFMBQQBSFDDIJPBEVOBQSFTBDPODPOUBUUPEJQSPUF[JPOF
QFSBQQBSFDDIJEFMMBDMBTTFEJQSPUF[JPOF*
7FSJGJDBSFSFHPMBSNFOUFMFWFOUVBMFQSFTFO[BEJEBOOJWJTJCJMJTVM
GJMPEJDPMMFHBNFOUPBMMBSFUF/POVTBSFMBQQBSFDDIJPTFJMGJMPEJ
DPMMFHBNFOUP¨EBOOFHHJBUP
*MDBWPEJDPMMFHBNFOUPEFWFFTTFSFDPSSJTQPOEFOUFBMNFOPBM
5JQP)3/'(
*OTUBMMBSFMBQQBSFDDIJPJONPEPTUBCJMFTVVOQJBOPEJMBWPSP
&WJUBSFDIFQFOFUSJVNJEJU
%PQP MVTP F JM SBGGSFEEBNFOUP MBQQBSFDDIJP EFWF FTTFSF QSPUFUUP
EBMMFJOUFNQFSJF QFSFTDPOVOBDPQFSUVSB
6PRQWDUHODSSDUHFFKLR
4UBDDBSFMBQQBSFDDIJPEBMMBDPSSFOUF5JSBSFMBQQBSFDDIJPEBM
CBTTP
$WWHQ]LRQH
%BOOJBMMBQQBSFDDIJP/POFTUSBSSFMBQQBSFDDIJPEBMMBMUP
nl
é
,QVWDOODWLHYRRUVFKULIW
%HODQJULMNHDDQZLM]LQJHQ
-FFTEF[FHFCSVJLTBBOXJK[JOH[PSHWVMEJHEPPSFOCFXBBSIFN
HPFE"MMFFOBMTEFJOCPVXPQEFTLVOEJHFXJK[FFODPOGPSNEJU
JOTUBMMBUJFWPPSTDISJGUXPSEUVJUHFWPFSEJTEFWFJMJHIFJECJKIFU
HFCSVJL HFHBSBOEFFSE %F JOTUBMMBUFVS JT WFSBOUXPPSEFMJKL WPPS FFO
HPFEFXFSLJOHPQEFQMBBUTWBOPQTUFMMJOH
"MMFFO FFO EBBSUPF CFWPFHE WBLNBO NBH IFU BQQBSBBU BBOTMVJUFO
7³³SBMMFXFSL[BBNIFEFOBBOIFUBQQBSBBUEJFOUIFUBQQBSBBU
TQBOOJOHTWSJKUFXPSEFOHFNBBLU
%SBBHCFTDIFSNIBOETDIPFOFOPNUFWPPSLPNFOEBUV
TOJKXPOEFOPQMPPQU0OEFSEFMFOEJFUJKEFOTEFNPOUBHF
UPFHBOLFMJKL[JKOLVOOFOTDIFSQFSBOEFOIFCCFO
7PPSEFJOTUBMMBUJFEJFOUBBOEFHFMEFOEFCPVXWFSPSEFOJOHFOFO
BBOEFWPPSTDISJGUFOWBOIFUFOFSHJFCFESJKGUFXPSEFOWPMEBBO
%JUBQQBSBBUWBMUPOEFSEFBQQBSBUFOLMBTTF CFTUFNEWPPSIFU
JOCPVXFOJOFFOLFVLFONFVCFM)FUBQQBSBBUEJFOUWPMHFOTEF
BBOXJK[JOHFO PQ EF JOCPVXTDIFUT UF XPSEFO JOHFCPVXE -FU PQ EF
NJOJNBMFBGTUBOEUVTTFOIFUBQQBSBBUFOEFLFVLFONVSFOPG
NFVCFMFOBBOEF[JKFOBDIUFSLBOU
%JUBQQBSBBUJTOJFUCFTUFNEWPPSHFCSVJLNFUFFOFYUFSOF
UJKETDIBLFMLMPLPGFFOFYUFSOFBGTUBOECFEJFOJOH
,QERXZPHXEHOYRRUEHUHLGHQ
)FUJOCPVXNFVCFMNPFUUFNQFSBUVVSCFTUFOEJH[JKOUPUp$%F
TUBCJMJUFJU WBO IFU JOCPVXNFVCFM NPFU PPL OB IFU BBOCSFOHFO WBO
EFVJUTQBSJOH FO[JKOHFXBBSCPSHE
.BBLFFOVJUTQBSJOHWPPS©©OPGNFFSEFSF7BSJPBQQBSBUFOJOIFU
XFSLCMBE WPMHFOT EF JOCPVXTDIFUT %F IPFL UVTTFO IFU TOJKWMBL FO
IFUXFSLCMBENPFUp[JKO
7FSXJKEFSBMMFTQBBOEFSTOBIFUNBLFOWBOEFVJUTQBSJOH
7FS[FHFMEFTOJKWMBLLFONFUFFOIJUUFCFTUFOEJHNJEEFM
)PVEFFONJOJNBMFBGTUBOEBBOWBONNWBOBGEFPOEFSLBOU
WBOIFUBQQBSBBUUPUBBOEFPOEFSEFMFOWBOIFULFVLFONFVCFM
%F BBOSBBLCFWFJMJHJOH NPFU EPPS IFU JOCPVXFO HFHBSBOEFFSE [JKO
*OEJFOEFPOEFSLBOUWBOIFUBQQBSBBUOBIFUJOCPVXFOLBO
XPSEFOBBOHFSBBLUEJFOUFSFFOBMMFFONFUHFSFFETDIBQ
VJUOFFNCBSFUVTTFOCPEFNUFXPSEFOHFNPOUFFSE)PVEFFO
NJOJNBMFBGTUBOEBBOWBONNWBOBGEFUVTTFOCPEFNUPUBBO
EFPOEFSLBOUWBOIFUBQQBSBBU
%LMKHWLQERXZHQYDQPHHUGHUH9DULRDSSDUDWHQ )PVE
SFLFOJOHNFUEFSVJNUFEJFOPEJHJTUVTTFOEFBQQBSBUFOWPPSEF
WFSCJOEJOHTMJKTU77%FBQQBSBUFOLVOOFOPPLJOBQBSUF
VJUTQBSJOHFOXPSEFOJOHFCPVXENFUJOBDIUOFNJOHWBOFFO
NJOJNBMFBGTUBOEUVTTFOEFBQQBSBUFOWBONN
(OHNWULVFKHDDQVOXLWLQJ
$POUSPMFFSEFIVJTJOTUBMMBUJFWPPSEBUVIFUBQQBSBBUBBOTMVJU-FU
PQEBUEFIVJTJOTUBMMBUJFWPPS[JFOJTWBOEFHFTDIJLUF[FLFSJOHFO
%FTQBOOJOHFOEFGSFRVFOUJFWBOIFUBQQBSBBUNPFUFO
PWFSFFOLPNFONFUEFFMFLUSJTDIFJOTUBMMBUJF [JFIFUUZQFQMBBUKF
)FUBQQBSBBUWBMUPOEFSEFBQQBSBUFOLMBTTF*FONBHBMMFFOPQ
FFOHFBBSEBBOTMVJUQVOUXPSEFOBBOHFTMPUFO
#JOOFOEFJOTUBMMBUJFNPFUFFOTDIFJEJOHTTDIBLFMBBSWPPSBMMF
QPMFONFUFFODPOUBDUPQFOJOHWBONJOJNBBMNNBBOXF[JH[JKO
PGIFUBQQBSBBUNPFUWJBFFOHFBBSEFTUFLLFSXPSEFO
BBOHFTMPUFO%F[FNPFUOBIFUJOCPVXFOOPHUPFHBOLFMJKL[JKO
8JKBEWJTFSFOPNDBDNCPWFOEFWMPFSFFOWPMHFOTEF
WPPSTDISJGUFOHF¯OTUBMMFFSEHFBBSETUPQDPOUBDUBDIUFSIFU
BQQBSBBUUFJOTUBMMFSFO
)FUQMBBUTFOWBOFFOTUPQDPOUBDUNBHBMMFFOEPPSFFO
FMFLUSPUFDIOJDVTXPSEFOVJUHFWPFSE)JFSCJKNPFUBBOBMMF
HFMEFOEFWPPSTDISJGUFOXPSEFOWPMEBBO
)FUBQQBSBBUNBHBMMFFONFUEFCJKHFWPFHEFBBOTMVJULBCFM
XPSEFOBBOHFTMPUFO
%FBBOTMVJULBCFMNBHOJFUXPSEFOHFLOJLUPGLMFNSBLFO
)FUBQQBSBBUCFIPPSUUPUEFBBOTMVJULMBTTF:%FBBOTMVJULBCFM
NBHBMMFFOEPPSEFLMBOUFOTFSWJDFXPSEFOWFSWBOHFO-FUPQEF
BBOXJK[JOHFOCFUSFGGFOEFIFULBCFMUZQFFOEFNJOJNBMFEJBNFUFS
+HWDSSDUDDWLQERXZHQ
.BSLFFS QSFDJFT IFU NJEEFO WBO EF VJUTQBSJOH #FWFTUJH EF MBOHF
CFWFTUJHJOHTSBJMBBOEFWPPSLBOUWBOEFVJUTQBSJOHFOEFLPSUF
CFWFTUJHJOHTSBJM BBO EF BDIUFSLBOU WBO EF VJUTQBSJOH %F OFVTKFT
WBOEFCFWFTUJHJOHTSBJMTNPFUFOPQIFUXFSLCMBESVTUFO%F
NJEEFONBSLFSJOH WBO EF CFWFTUJHJOHTSBJMT NPFU FYBDU BBOTMVJUFO
PQEFNJEEFONBSLFSJOHWBOEFVJUTQBSJOHJOIFUXFSLCMBE
$DQZLM]LQJ ;FUCJKXFSLCMBEFOWBOTUFFOEFCFWFTUJHJOHTSBJMT
WBTUNFUFFOUFNQFSBUVVSCFTUFOEJHFUXFFDPNQPOFOUFOMJKN
NFUBBMPQTUFFO
#JKFFODPNCJOBUJFNFUEFBGEFLLJOH7%
#FWFTUJHEFBGEFLLJOHW³³SIFUJOCPVXFOBBOIFUBQQBSBBU
[JFNPOUBHFIBOEMFJEJOH7%
1MBBUT IFU BQQBSBBU JO EF VJUTQBSJOH %F CFWFTUJHJOHTQVOUFO WBO
IFUBQQBSBBUNPFUFOQSFDJFTPQEFLMFNWFSFOMJHHFO%SVLIFU
BQQBSBBUTUFWJHJOIFUXFSLCMBE 'HEHYHVWLJLQJVSXQWHQYDQ
KHWDSSDUDDWPRHWHQLQGHNOHPYHUHQYDVWNOLNNHQ
([WUDDDQZLM]LQJHQYRRUGHEXLWHQLQERXZ
(FCSVJLIFUBQQBSBBUNFUFFOGPVUTUSPPNCFWFJMJHJOH 3$%NFU
FFOVJUTDIBLFMTUSPPNWBONBYJNBBMN"
.POUFFSFFOTUFLLFSEJFHFTDIJLUJTWPPSCVJUFOBBOEF
BBOTMVJULBCFM MFUPQEFQMBBUTFMJKLFWPPSTDISJGUFO
4MVJUIFUBQQBSBBUBBOPQFFOTUPQDPOUBDUNFUSBOEBBSEF WPPS
BQQBSBUFOEJFWBMMFOPOEFSEFBQQBSBUFOLMBTTF*
$POUSPMFFSEFBBOTMVJULBCFMSFHFMNBUJHPQUFLFOFOWBO
CFTDIBEJHJOH(FCSVJLIFUBQQBSBBUOJFUXBOOFFSEF
BBOTMVJULBCFMJTCFTDIBEJHE
%FBBOTMVJULBCFMEJFOUUFONJOTUFWBOIFUUZQF)3/'(UF
[JKO
)FUBQQBSBBUEJFOUTUFWJHJOFFOXFSLCMBEUFXPSEFOJOHFCPVXE
7PPSLPNEBUFSWPDIUJOIFUBQQBSBBUESJOHU
)FUBQQBSBBUEJFOUOBEBUIFUJTHFCSVJLUFOBGHFLPFMEUFXPSEFO
CFTDIFSNE UFHFO XFFSTJOWMPFEFO CJKW EPPS IFU QMBBUTFO WBO FFO
BGEFLLJOH
+HWDSSDUDDWXLWERXZHQ
)BBMEFTQBOOJOHWBOIFUBQQBSBBU%SVLIFUBQQBSBBUFSWBO
POEFSFOBGVJU
$WWHQWLH
#FTDIBEJHJOHWBOIFUBQQBSBBU)FUBQQBSBBUOJFUWBOBGEF
CPWFOLBOUFSVJUXSJLLFO
es
Û
*OTUSVDDJPOFTEFNPOUBKF
&RQVHMRV\DGYHUWHQFLDV
-FFSDPOBUFODJ³OFTUBTJOTUSVDDJPOFTZDPOTFSWBSMBT4PMBNFOUF
VO NPOUBKF QSPGFTJPOBM DPOGPSNF B FTUBT JOTUSVDDJPOFT EF NPOUBKF
QVFEFHBSBOUJ[BSVOVTPTFHVSPEFMBQBSBUP&MJOTUBMBEPSFT
SFTQPOTBCMFEFMGVODJPOBNJFOUPQFSGFDUPFOFMMVHBSEF
JOTUBMBDJ³O
&MBQBSBUPTPMPIBEFTFSDPOFDUBEPQPSVOU©DOJDPBVUPSJ[BEP
"OUFTEFSFBMJ[BSDVBMRVJFSUSBCBKPTFIBEFDPSUBSFMTVNJOJTUSP
FM©DUSJDP
6UJMJDFHVBOUFTEFQSPUFDDJ³OQBSBFWJUBSDPSUBSTF-BTQJF[BTRVF
RVFEBOEFTDVCJFSUBTEVSBOUFFMNPOUBKFQPESBOUFOFSCPSEFT
BGJMBEPT
1BSBMBJOTUBMBDJ³OTFIBOEFUFOFSFODVFOUBMBTOPSNBUJWBTEF
DPOTUSVDDJ³OFOWJHPSBTDPNPMBTOPSNBUJWBTEFMBDPNQB±B
FM©DUSJDBEFTVNJOJTUSPSFHJPOBM
&TUFBQBSBUPDPSSFTQPOEFBMBDMBTFEFBQBSBUP QBSBFMNPOUBKF
FONVFCMFTEFDPDJOB4FIBEFJOTUBMBSDPOGPSNFBMDSPRVJTEF
NPOUBKF5FOFSFODVFOUBMBEJTUBODJBNOJNBSFTQFDUPBMBT
QBSFEFTMBUFSBMFTPCJFOSFTQFDUPBQBSUFTEFMPTNVFCMFTZ
SFTQFDUPMBEPQPTUFSJPS
&TUFBQBSBUPOPFTU¡QSFWJTUPQBSBFMGVODJPOBNJFOUPDPOVOSFMPK
UFNQPSJ[BEPSFYUFSOPPVONBOEPBEJTUBODJBFYUFSOP
